Understanding Group Psychotherapy

written by Tracy Miles

(originally published at www.energytap.ca June 8, 2021)

Sometimes people ask us, what is group therapy? Many people do not understand what group therapy is and how it works. This post is about bringing you closer to being informed.

At Energy Tap and Life Medicine, we offer group therapy. This is a form of psychotherapy that involves sitting with one therapist, a physician who is also trained in psychotherapy, and other participants.

In a group, therapists are working with several people at the same time. Some people who chose group psychotherapy use it as their only form of psychotherapy and others integrate group into their individual experience.

We use an interpersonal approach to offering group:

We focus on your interpersonal relationships and social interactions, including how much support you receive and take from others and the impact these relationships are having on you. As the group begins to form, so do the relationships between members. What eventually happens is that these relationships begin to bring out the same behaviours and defenses you use in your everyday life and relationships. The group members and facilitators help you to grow in awareness of how you are impacting others and how others are impacting you. This is done through a process of connection and feedback.

Groups often involve around 8 to 12 individuals (although it is possible to have more participants, our groups remain at a cap of 8 because of COVID-19 protocols). The group meets once a week for 75 minutes.

 Techniques

So, what does a typical group therapy session look like? The group will meet in a one of our larger rooms where comfortable chairs are arranged in a large circle so that each member can see every other person in the group.

A first session might begin with members of the group introducing themselves and sharing why they are in group therapy. Members might also share their experiences.

In our groups we encourage a more free-form style of dialogue, where each member participates as he or she sees fit. Our therapists do not have a specific plan for how each session goes. Members of the group choose when and what they are sharing about. Our therapists do encourage dialogue amongst the group members once a person has shared the content of their experiences.

Group therapy is used to treat a wide variety of conditions, including:

  • Depression

  • Generalized anxiety disorder

  • Panic disorder

  • Phobias

  • Post-traumatic stress disorder

  • Substance use

  • And more

In addition to mental health conditions, group psychotherapy has been found to help people cope with the following:

  • Anger management

  • Chronic pain

  • Chronic illness

  • Chronic stress

  • Divorce

  • Domestic violence

  • Grief and loss

  • And more

In The Theory and Practice of Group Psychotherapy, Irvin D. Yalom outlines the key therapeutic principles:

Altruism: Group members can share their strengths and help others in the group, which can boost self-esteem and confidence.

Catharsis: Sharing feelings and experiences with a group of people can help relieve pain, guilt, or stress. It can be very healing to have others witness what you are experiencing.

The corrective recapitulation of the primary family group: The therapy group is much like a family in some ways. Within the group, each member can explore how childhood experiences contributed to personality and behaviors. They can also learn to avoid behaviors that are destructive or unhelpful in real life.

Development of socialization techniques: The group setting is a great place to practice new behaviors. The setting is safe and supportive, allowing group members to experiment without the fear of failure.

Existential factors: While working within a group offers support and guidance, group therapy helps members realize that they are responsible for their own lives, actions, and choices.

Group cohesiveness: Because the group is united in a common goal, members gain a sense of belonging and acceptance.

Imparting information: Group members can help each other by sharing information.

Imitative behavior: Individuals can model the behavior of other members of the group or learn from the behavior of the therapist.

Instills hope: The group contains members at different stages of the treatment process. Seeing people who are coping or recovering gives hope to those at the beginning of the process.

Interpersonal learning: By interacting with other people and receiving feedback from the group and the therapist, members of the group can gain a greater understanding of themselves.

Universality: Being part of a group of people who have the same experiences helps people see that what they are going through is universal and that they are not alone.

Who is best suited for group therapy?

People who join an interpersonal therapy group usually want to be able to relate better with others and to feel better about themselves. Reasons a person may join an interpersonal group may include:

  • You often feeling angry, frustrated, or dissatisfied in relationships

  • You are having difficulty trusting others

  • You are struggling to create close (or meaningful) relationships

  • You feel that you are stuck in a cycle of needing to please others

  • You struggle to communicate your thoughts, feelings, and needs directly

  • You are controlling (or easily controlled) in relationships

  • You experience anxiety in social situations

  • You are struggling with substance use or addiction

  • You frequently experience loneliness

  • You find that you have to manipulate others to get your needs met

  • You have trouble with self-esteem

Benefits of Group Therapy

The principal advantages of group therapy include:

Group therapy allows people to receive the support and encouragement of the other members of the group. People participating in the group can see that others are going through the same thing, which can help them feel less alone.

Group members can serve as role models for other members of the group. By observing someone successfully coping with a problem, other members of the group can see that there is hope for recovery. As each person progresses, they can, in turn, serve as a role model and support figure for others. This can help foster feelings of success and accomplishment.

Group therapy is often very affordable. Instead of focusing on just one client at a time, the therapist can devote his or her time to a much larger group of people.

Group therapy offers a safe haven. The setting allows people to practice behaviors and actions within the safety and security of the group.

By working in a group, the therapist can see first-hand how each person responds to other people and behaves in social situations. Using this information, the therapist can provide valuable feedback to each client.

Things you will need to Consider AND FAQS

If you or someone you love is thinking about group therapy, there are several things you should know:

You need to be willing to share and commit to a 6-month process. The group takes a while to form so you need to be patient with the process

It’s not meant for crisis, if you are experiencing crisis, individual therapy is a better choice than group therapy.

How will my relational patterns play out in the group?

It is important to see how group is a social microcosm of what happens in everyday life. People who avoid connection in life avoid connecting in group, people who consistently experience anger in life experience anger in group, people who avoid conflict in life avoid conflict in group, and people who have difficulty with trust in life struggle with trust in group. The unconscious relational patterns that govern our lives outside of group (which we have learned over the course of our life) govern our lives in group. The important difference between everyday life and group is that in group we are given the opportunity to become aware of how these patterns play out and why, which over time allows us to begin to make different choices about how we relate with ourselves and others. Quite simply, this process can be very freeing.

Do I need to be in individual therapy to be in an interpersonal group?

This depends. Some people benefit from continuing to see their individual therapist, and they participate in group because it provides the opportunity to try out what they may be working on in individual therapy. Being in a group can also help stimulate things to work on in individual therapy.

Additionally, some people choose to continue to see their individual therapist but do so on a less frequent basis. All of that said, a person does not have to be in individual therapy to be in a therapy group.

Will I be forced to cry, share, or give feedback?

Not at all. You will not have to do anything you do not want to do. Like a lot of things, though, the amount of effort you put into group will be reflected in the outcome you obtain. Everyone is encouraged to be as present as possible and to be engaged in the process. By being present and engaged you not only help yourself but you also help other group members.

How do I know things will remain confidential?

Members in the group make an agreement to keep what is said in group completely confidential. In fact, everyone in group signs a group agreement that stipulates that they will keep the material discussed in group confidential. Members are allowed to talk about their own experience in group with whomever they like but agree to refrain from talking about other group members. The group therapist is required to keep everything said in group confidential.

How long do I need to be in the group?

This depends. As a general rule, we ask that you give the process about 6 months. The scientific evidence shows that group psychotherapy begins to show significant benefit around the 3 month mark. We therefore encourage group members to commit to at least 3 months of participation, in group, and preferably 6-months.

What if I decide I want to leave?

You can always leave the group. We ask that you let the other group members know about your intent to leave and give the group enough time (preferably a session or two) to process your departure. It is preferable to have closure when people leave and we understand that sometimes this is not a possibility.

This whole process sounds interesting but different. Is getting accustomed to the group challenging?
The answer to this question is yes and no. Usually in the beginning, as a group is forming, there is a certain amount of discomfort among everyone as things can feel a little formal. People are trying to get a sense of their place in the group. After a period of time, though, the group figures out how to make use of the opportunity they have together. Members become more open and honest about their moment-to-moment reactions and develop greater comfort with authentic engagement.

Spot of tea?

written by Ryan Oakeson, edited by Dr Joshua Weiss

When it comes to our health — whether mental or physical — we often look for the “magic” pill that’s going to make it all better. Corporations are smart when it comes to appealing to this desire; they often market their products with deliberate exaggerations and sell products that don’t always turn out as advertised. This may lead to mistrust and self-doubt—is there anything out there that can genuinely help me on my health journey? The beautiful thing about Life Medicine is that we’re not here to advertise any specific product or magic pills. We’re here to help you to weigh your options and consider lifestyle choices that are proven by science to help you make the changes you want to without any gimmicks or empty promises. Though we do have a few pearls that might help you along the way…

 

This instalment will focus on a simple product that you can buy the next time you’re at the grocery store to help take care of your body. It’s all-natural and easy to find. It’s tea!

 

            As I was writing this post, I steeped a cup of green tea to enjoy while researching. I already had the topic of heart health and tea consumption in mind. I didn’t know much about it before my own research, though I was excited to share my findings. It was ironic—as I was putting my box of bags back in the cupboard, I noticed part of the label stated: “can help support a healthy heart”. I smiled and wondered, how many people were buying tea with the intention of heart health, how much tea should be consumed for optimal support, and are there any differences between black and green and herbal tea? So let’s dive in and answer these and other questions. Whether you do or don’t already drink tea, I’m about to spill it.

             

For several decades, researchers have been examining the beneficial effects of tea on cardiovascular health. One 2010 paper  examined the benefits of tea for coronary artery disease - excessive plaque buildup in the heart’s arteries - and demonstrated that green tea had a greater effect of 28% reduced coronary artery disease risk than black tea, which didn’t really show any risk reduction. Another paper analyzed intake of coffee, black, green, and oolong tea in Japanese men and women and found that moderate consumption (>1 cups a day) of caffeinated coffee, green, and oolong tea had a relationship with lower mortality risk rate from cardiovascular disease. Unbelievably, significant consumption of green tea decreased womens’ risk of dying of cardiovascular disease by 38% and oolong tea (>1 cup/day) decreased men’s risk of dying by 61%!

 

A paper published in 2000 found that there is clear data here to suggest that tea—green tea in particular—can prevent heart and arterial disease by decreasing cholesterol and reduced blood pressure. Other papers found tea has natural anti-platelet, anti-inflammatory, and mechanisms to help manage cholesterol found in tea. But what exactly could it be in the tea that is doing all of this?

 

Polyphenols!

 

What exactly are polyphenols? They are naturally occurring metabolites in plants that, when consumed, behave as dietary antioxidants. Antioxidants can help prevent and manage various cancers and cardiovascular conditions (Mukhtar & Ahmad, 2000; Pandey & Rizvi, 2009). There are lots of different polyphenols, most of which are found in fruits and vegetables. But when tea leaves are harvested, dried, and then brewed, the polyphenols that naturally occur in the leaves become concentrated and ready to be absorbed by you, the tea drinker!

 

So next time you wake up and feel the need for that caffeine boost to get you going or midway through the day to keep you going, think about your alternatives to coffee and energy drinks. You could add a quick cup of tea along alongside your coffee, not only to zest up your daily routine, but to introduce those precious polyphenols into your diet. It may not be a magic pill, but drinking tea is a great place to start for preventing our risk of heart disease and optimizing our health. It’s your life, tea can make it last longer!

 

 

Trust Your Gut

by Ryan Oakeson

It’s time for Life Medicine’s newest monthly blog instalment, Hallelujah!

This month’s we’ll focus on diet and diabetes. Even if you don’t have diabetes, I promise you’ll learn something new. It is incredible how big of an effect diet can have in the treatment of diabetes - and it’s also true that a balanced, conscious, and healthy diet carries enormous benefits for for general health as well as during the treatment and prevention of countless other chronic diseases. So, tune in and get ready to learn an easy yet effective way to change your life. And no don’t worry, your favourite carbs aren’t going anywhere!

 

Throughout this post, I will be making several references to “healthy” and “unhealthy” food. Basically, what I mean by these terms is that when we consistently eat the ‘healthy’ food, we tend to either see benefits to our health - or at least no negative effects. On the contrary, when we eat large amounts of the ‘unhealthy’ foods and neglect the healthy ones, we may feel full—which undoubtedly feels better than being hungry—but these foods will have long term negative effects to our physical and mental health.

 

So let’s dig in.

In 2021, food is fast, and some food is certainly cheap. Food is easy. There’s nothing like a classic hamburger, fries, and a soft drink from your favorite fast-food restaurant after a long day at work when you don’t have any energy to cook. In this state, you need something, anything in your stomach ASAP! But what are the repercussions, if any? Does the convenience have any impact on our health? For one thing, when food has been processed or comes from places like fast-food chains, usually a lot of the nutritional value has been lost or traded with salt, fat or other additives (Cornwell et al., 2018; Machado et al., 2019). In order to survive the logistical process of getting to your plate, those ultra-processed foods are also filled with preservatives—not to mention sugar. Ya, let’s talk about that good ole’ sweet stuff.

 

Sugar—or glucose-fructose—is everywhere. It’s often derived and processed from corn and it’s extremely versatile. There is a high likelihood that if you go into your fridge or cupboards right now, you will find several products listing a word that ends with “-ose” in their ingredient lists. That just means—with some exceptions—that there’s some form of sugar in it. Eating too many of these types of food over a long period of time can be very unhealthy. Don’t get me wrong, there are healthy, naturally occurring sugars—such as in fruit! These latter sugars can be healthy in the sense that they are not processed and come packaged in healthy bundles containing other nutrients like fiber and vitamins. Regardless—sugar is sugar. And any unhealthy amount of sugar can have severe consequences to our health when consumed over years or decades.

 

Diabetes is a disease that can be classified in two different ways: type 1 is caused by genetic factors and those individuals are born with the partial or complete inability to produce insulin; type 2 diabetics generally develop an inability to respond to insulin, usually due to lifestyle factors. Insulin comes from the pancreas and is a hormone that helps the body regulate the amount of glucose that’s in your blood. Basically, when your body doesn’t have insulin to regulate your blood sugar, there will be dangerous fluctuations in your blood sugar levels. This can have serious health consequences e.g., numbness and tingling in the limbs, along with other severe conditions such as heart disease, blindness, and kidney failure. Type 1 diabetes cannot yet be cured; however, type 2 diabetes can often be partially or completely reversed with dedication to lifestyle modification, and this will be the type that we will focus on.

 

Again, I’m not saying that we must hit the gym every day to see significant changes, but what I am saying is that focusing on what we put in our bodies as well as what we do with our bodies, will have significant, long term, health benefits.

 

There are several well-known diets out there that I’m sure you are familiar with: keto, angus, paleo, vegetarian/vegan, etc. Well, the diet that we will focus on is the Mediterranean diet. This diet consists of eating lots of fruits and vegetables, legumes, nuts, whole grains, unsaturated fats—like in olive oil- some seafood, and even alcohol (in moderation). Basically, if you think about the Mediterranean Sea, imagine all the things you might find around that area. That’s what you would include on your plate!

 

Research has found that adhering to a Mediterranean diet lowers the risk of developing diabetes in middle aged adults (O’Connor et al., 2020). This might not mean much to you if you have diabetes, but it shows that there are diets that help the prevent the development of Type 2. If you do have diabetes, a Mediterranean, low-carbohydrate diet has been found to not only help control blood sugar better than a low-fat diet, but also controls coronary risk factors too (Esposito et al., 2009). Now if you are a Type 2 diabetic and you tie that in with a balance of regular exercise, you can start seeing tvast improvements to your glucose control. 

That is a big deal! To further demonstrate the benefits of this diet, an excellent resource to find further sources can be found using this link. There you will find that the list goes on with the health benefits included in eating the Mediterranean diet including but not limited to: lower inflammation, antioxidants to boost the immune system, improvements to memory and cognitive function, a reduced risk of dementia, and actual positive changes in the structure of your brain! If you’re interested, there’s also a diet specifically targetting the relationship between food and with mental health, which is called the MIND diet. This diet is very similar to the Mediterranean with respect to the foods being eaten.

 

Dieting is hard. It takes motivation, dedication, and contemplation. But if you trust your gut, your gut will take care of you!

 

Mind Matters Now

Mind Matters Now

 by Ryan Oakeson

“What we are today comes from our thoughts of yesterday, and our present thoughts build our life of tomorrow: our life is the creation of our mind.” - Buddha

 

Picture yourself walking down a sidewalk and you see an old acquaintance whom you haven’t seen in several years approaching you. You might start off with that typical, “Hey! How are you?” which leads to several other topics of small talk in passing, one being perhaps the weather or how well the person looks. Now imagine living in a world where rather the physique we comment on each other’s psyche. It seems strange, maybe even a bit scary. How would they see me in that light? Would I be more motivated to try to improve my mental health? Or is my current state considered “healthy”? We might often feel as though we don’t want to burden others with whatever struggles we are going though mentally i.e., it could be considered not the most “appropriate” topic for small conversation.

It’s also harder to recognize changes in mental health over time as opposed to physical health characteristics, so progress often goes undetected and equally unpraised by ourselves and our peers. Mental health is private and heavily stigmatized; however, there is hope! Mental health and physical health are strongly linked, perhaps stronger than most tend to realize. That being said, let’s focus on those physical lifestyle choices that we make which have direct associations, and dare I say, causations with our mental health. In this journey together, we will look at lifestyle modifications that have evidence-based improvements on mental health and chronic disease e.g., coronary heart disease and diabetes. And don’t worry, this blog will not implore you to go to the gym three hours a day, twice a day, six days a week, or do a triathlon each month. While exercise is important and will play a theme, lifestyle topics we will focus on will explore topics like diet, meditation, leisure activities, and much more. So let us begin our journey together, starting with (as you might have guessed) mental health!

 

            I want to follow with the disclaimer that lifestyle choices are extremely important when it comes to mental health, but these posts are not here to undermine the effectiveness of various talk therapies and psychiatric pharmaceuticals. These posts are for the people out there looking for alternatives or complements to the traditional routes of medicine and therapy.

 

            This month’s lifestyle modification topic is—drum roll please: Meditation!

 

While meditation has been around for centuries long before Buddha, meditation has become a mainstream concept in the West all thanks to Buddhism. Meditation is a process in which you control and focus your breathing and attention in such a way to quiet your mind and allow thoughts and sensations to flow through you freely. In essence, you focus on the present moment, the Now. One of the many symptoms of mental health conditions such as depression is rumination—or the constant thinking about a thought—one that is often negative. However, there is also more to depression than negative thoughts; there is also a complex dysregulation of structures and processes located in the brain (e.g., anterior cingulate cortex, amygdala, hippocampus, etc.) and these dysregulations can cause observable and measurable changes in behavior and thinking (Edenfield, T. M. & Saeed, A., 2012). So, hopefully it should start to make sense, right?

Quieting your mind or being more mindful of your thoughts, helps to sort of recognize those ruminations and allow your thoughts to exist freely without any negative focus. Alas, once you’re in a comfortable position to try meditating, you may find that it is more difficult to quiet that noisy mind than you thought, or that it’s not relaxing at all! Don’t be discouraged—like all things, practice makes perfect. There are several reliable resources to help get you in the right mode or state of mind e.g., meditation apps, guided meditations on YouTube. You may even be able to find local resources near you that offer a community of similar thinking and feeling individuals like I did, assuming you’re comfortable enough to put yourself in new territory, that is.

           

In undergrad, I was able to find a small community of individuals interested in Buddhism. Every Thursday we would meet for an hour which included a short intro to Buddhism which was followed by a guided meditation. The “class” was orientated to beginners and was extremely inclusive. At first, I was nervous and uncomfortable. I wasn’t sure if I was meditating correctly; but as I continued to go for a few months, I found the experience extremely pleasing—mainly because of the community and how the actual meditating became easier and more comfortable. I really felt my thoughts and behaviors start to become more mindful!

 

This anecdote leads me to our next point; mindful meditation has been an interest to scientific studies regarding anxiety and depression, and yes, the results are promising! Neuroscientists concerned with meditation have found that through practice and consistency, individuals with mental health conditions were able to change their thought patterns which in turn manipulated how the dysregulated brain regions and processes functioned, resulting in increased activation and significant brain changes in imaging studies (Marchand, 2014). Meaning, the better you get at meditating, the more control you have over your attention and emotions, i.e., less ruminating. Additionally, in a 2017 study, two groups of individuals with depression were randomized to either meditate or exercise for one hour, three days a week, for 10 weeks. The results concluded that mindfulness mediation group was found to have a greater effect, or a significant decrease in depression scores than the exercise group had over the same period of those 10 weeks (Allen, C., Canizales, R., & Robbins, E., 2021).

 

So, it seems if we can target our thoughts in a mindful way, we may just be able to change our brain in a positive way, all while skipping the gym fees and that grunting, sweaty gym bro next to you. And that can all start right now with your next breath!